Part D · Putting It Together

Retention Offers with a Control Group

Retention offers look successful by redemption, but many redeemers would have stayed anyway. Only a control group reveals the real effect.

Retention Offers with a Control Group · Illustrated by Hendra Saputra with AI assistanceSelect the illustration to explore it at a larger size.

The idea

Define customer segments before assignment, then randomise comparable customers within each segment to offer and control groups. A 10% control is illustrative, not a universal sample-size rule: use baseline outcomes, expected effect and variability to choose the size. After an appropriate observation period, compare contribution per assigned customer, including offer costs and relevant customer outcomes. A 90-day window is an example.

Use it thoughtfully

  • Hold out a random 10% control group.
  • Match offer value to segment lifetime value.
  • Measure contribution after 90 days, not redemptions.

An example

ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLE: A retention offer shows 40% redemption, but the control group stayed at almost the same rate, so the offer is redesigned for higher-risk customers.

A question to try

What was the retention rate of the control group in your last retention campaign?

A useful framework is a starting point, not a guarantee. Effects vary with the audience, product and situation. Use truthful evidence, respect customer choice, and test the result.

Connect the ideas

Illustration

Use + and − to zoom, scroll to explore, or Escape to close. Please seek permission before reusing an illustration.